Knickerbocker on the Lake: A Historic Gem

Nestled on the shores of Lake Michigan, The Knickerbocker on the Lake is a historic landmark that has gracefully stood the test of time in Milwaukee. With a storied past that intertwines with the city's own growth and evolution, this iconic hotel and condo complex offers more than just a place to stay – it provides a journey through history.  Sleepy Cat MKE celebrates that history with three uniquely designed Airbnbs. 

Early Beginnings: The Roaring Twenties

The Knickerbocker on the Lake opened its doors in 1929. It was built at a cost of $1 million during a boom of apartment construction. This period was marked by economic prosperity, cultural dynamism, and architectural innovation. The building itself is a testament to the Art Deco style, which was popular during the era.

The Knickerbocker is on the National Register of Historic Places. Its registration notes, “The construction of the Knickerbocker Hotel coincides with the development of transient lodging away from railroad-oriented hotels to those that served a new automobile-owning group of travelers. These new hotels could be located away from railroads and did not have to be located in the immediate Downtown since the automobile provided more flexible transportation.”

“The residential hotel provided an alternative for transients brought about by the automobile. Because the Knickerbocker is one of the two best remaining examples of residential hotel construction in Milwaukee, and because this type of construction was important in the densification of the central city and represents a particular lifestyle of the middle and upper classes in the early 20th century, it is a significant architectural landmark in Milwaukee.”

The Great Depression and World War II

Despite its grand opening, The Knickerbocker faced immediate challenges with the onset of the Great Depression. However, its strategic location and reputation for elegance allowed it to maintain a steady clientele. During World War II, the hotel adapted to the times, hosting military personnel and events that supported the war effort. This adaptability would become a hallmark of The Knickerbocker's enduring legacy.

Following the war, the Knickerbocker flourished. The 1950s and 60s saw Milwaukee growing rapidly, and the hotel capitalized on the boom by modernizing its facilities. The introduction of contemporary amenities ensured that it remained competitive in an evolving market, attracting business travelers and tourists alike. The hotel's ballroom, The Red Lion Room,  became a popular venue for social events, weddings, and conferences, solidifying its status as a community hub. Many performers of the time, such as Sammy Davis Jr., performed there.

The Shift to Condominiums and Modernization

In the 1980s, The Knickerbocker underwent a significant transformation. Recognizing the changing landscape of urban living, the decision was made to convert part of the hotel into condominiums. This innovative move allowed the building to cater to a new generation of residents seeking the convenience of city living with the charm of historic architecture. The mixed-use model, combining hotel services with private residences, has been key to its sustained relevance. While the famed Red Lion Room is long gone, the building hosts two restaurant spaces, a laundry room, an exercise room, spa, and salon. 

Entering the 21st century, The Knickerbocker on the Lake has continued to balance preservation with modernization. Efforts have been made to maintain its historic charm while upgrading the infrastructure to meet contemporary standards. This delicate balance is evident in the restoration of its elegant lobby, the maintenance of original architectural details, and the inclusion of modern conveniences.

Sleepy Cat MKE

In 2022, Sleepy Cat’s owners Scott and Noreena, decided to expand their Airbnb holdings by purchasing a unit in the historic hotel. Over the years they’ve dined at several of the Knickerbocker’s restaurants and had friends who lived in the building. They loved the historic character of the building and felt a downtown Airbnb made sense for them. By 2024 their holdings have grown to three units at The Knickerbocker on the Lake each with its own unique style. The Beer Barons’ Retreat features stories and artifacts from Milwaukee’s brewing past and combines modern amenities with a Victorian era styling. The Jewel Box highlights the building’s Art Deco stylings as well as a view of the historic Wisconsin Gas Building and its jewel toned flame. And finally, the Blue Sky Escape combines a more contemporary feel with the peace and quietness of a top floor getaway. 

Whether you’re a history buff, an architecture enthusiast, or someone simply looking for a unique place to stay, The Knickerbocker on the Lake and Sleepy Cat’s stylish Airbnbs offer an experience that is truly timeless.